The sports I consume are basic and therefore in-line with most other Americans (football, baseball, basketball), but I'll probably write some stuff about personal expereinces (badminton).

I FUCKING HATE THIS STRATEGY

The Nets trading for Paul Pierce/Kevin Garnett, the Jets and Aaron Rodgers, the Broncos and Russel Wilson, Irving/Harden/Durant to the Nets, Westbrook to the Lakers.

What do all of these roster decisions have in common? They involve trading away either a teams draft capital, it's depth, or both for aging superstars. None of these teams won a championship after trading for these players. In fact, three out of five of those teams didn't make the playoffs the season after acquiring said players. What I hate even more is that some of these athletes try to dictate their team's organizational decisions after they join. Even if you're a complete savant in your sport along with having achieved extraordinary success within your career (see Lebron James, Tom Brady), you should still generally stay out of organizational decsions and choose a team whos leadership has a proven track record of achivement within the sport. Situations like Aaron Rodgers in New York where a single player demonstrates extreme influence over an organizations roster and coaching personnel are the worst cases. Rodgers and his demand for roster control have led to a 3-8 record for the Jets this season, with both the head coach and general manager being fired because they had to listen to their "all-knowing" superstar. Rodgers hasn't even played well this season, which is like, the whole point of trading your draft futures and handing over control of your team over to a single player.

In the words of Branch Rickety, the baseball executive who brought Jackie Robinson to the Brookyln Dodgers and broke the color barrier:

"Trade a player a year too early rather than a year too late."

Linked below is a descriptive essay about Oracle Park I wrote for my English class. It's the best thing I've ever written (not a high bar). I chose Oracle Park because there's dozens of different sensations I associated with a game there, starting and ending with the journey to the park. ~1400 words.

Third and King

Jesse Winker 10/02/2024

My first Giants game last season came on April 8th. I was super excited because Blake Snell, the largest acquisition of the offseason, was debuting. He had a horrible game, and the Giants got blown out by seven runs.

The best part of that day came before the game, during batting practice. As I normally do, I was trying (and failing) to catch balls in left field. At some point, one of the outfielders, Jesse Winker, came up to the warning track and asked in my general direction: "Did they change the foul grounds recently?" I knew the answer! Back in 2020, the Giants made some renovations, expanding the video board, shutting the holes in left field to prevent windflow, and moving the bullpens from foul grounds to the outfield. I didn't answer because of a combination of shock and spite: I rarely saw opposing players interact with fans, especially me, and as loyal fan, I would never do something that could possibly hurt my beloved Giants (of course this is dumb, but I will always be a dumb sports fan). Instead, somebody standing next to me answered the question. He could probably have asked a coach or a fellow teammate, but he took the time to kindly interact with the fans, and I still think about that interaction once in a while.

I was on the bus coming back from my dermatology appointment today, and I saw on my phone that the Mets were leading the Brewers by one run after eight innings in game three of a three game wild card series. I opened up the game on my phone, I recognized the hitter who was up to bat: it was Winker! He got hit by a pitch, and he advanced to first base with two outs. He hit his head hard while stealing second, and the Milwaukee crowd booed him for taking his time to stand up. Winker had been hit by two pitches that game, and that combined with getting booed made him visually agitated. He scored a few pitches later on a Sterling Marte double. As he crossed home plate, he slammed his helmet down, breaking it into pieces. The image of Winker slamming his helmet while screaming at his teammates is pretty awesome.

Winker scoring that run seemed to kill any energy the Brewers had left in them for a late comeback, and the Mets went on to win and advance. I think it's really cool that a player that I interacted with (if you can call it that) had a big impact on a playoff game. After doing some research, Winker was traded from the Nationals to the Mets in the middle of this season, and he also had a huge triple in game one of this Wild Card series. While he was sprinting, he yelled "fuck you" at one the Brewers players, and the player told him "meet me in the parking lot." Looking at his history that includes fights and effort issues, he doesn't seem like the best teammate, but I'll choose to judge him off my one experience with him, where he came off as cordial.

All the best for Jesse Winker.

PRESS THE ICON WITH AN ARROW TO THE BOTTOM RIGHT OF THE TEXT BOX TO LOGIN AND COMMENT.

Comments

Not using Html Comment Box  yet?
Russell Westbrook · Nov 21, 2024

Russell Westbrick

Russell Westbrook · Nov 21, 2024

@Russell Westbrook, Russell Westbrick

Will Jacobson · Nov 21, 2024

AARON RODGERS AND LEBRON JAMES? ON MY WEBSITE?

Aaron Rodgers · Nov 21, 2024

Look, I get the criticism. When a team brings in a player like me, they’re not just expecting results—they’re expecting leadership and a championship mentality. But let’s not pretend the organizations in those situations are blameless. If a team is willing to mortgage its future, that’s on the front office. I didn’t force anyone to make those trades or decisions—they did that because they believed it would work.

Do I push for input? Of course. I’ve been around this game long enough to know what works and what doesn’t. If I see areas where we can improve, I’m going to speak up. But let’s not act like the 3-8 record in New York is solely on me. Injuries, lack of execution, and organizational issues played huge roles. A winning team isn’t just about one guy—it’s about the system, culture, and support.

That said, I respect the point about overreliance on stars. You can’t trade away depth and draft capital without a plan for the future. Leadership needs to have a clear direction, and players need to trust it. Teams succeed when everyone stays in their lane.

Robert Salah · Nov 21, 2024

@Aaron Rodgers
fuck you you lost me my job

Lebron James · Nov 21, 2024

I hear you, and I agree—trading away your team’s future for aging stars is a risky move that often doesn’t pay off. Depth and draft picks are the backbone of sustained success, and when you mortgage them for a quick fix, you’re betting everything on a narrow window. If the superstar doesn’t deliver immediately—whether due to injuries, age, or chemistry issues—you’re left with nothing to build on.

I’ve been blessed to play for organizations that took big swings, but even I’ve seen how tricky it can be. Look at how the Lakers struggled after the Westbrook trade—losing depth and flexibility made things harder for everyone. You need a balanced roster and a long-term plan. One player—no matter how talented—can’t do it all.

And yeah, players like Aaron Rodgers demanding roster control? That’s dangerous territory. Leadership needs to stay in the hands of people who know how to build a team. Even stars like me can’t replace that expertise. The best organizations, like Miami or Cleveland when we won, had clear direction from the top.

Branch Rickey was right: it’s better to make a tough decision early than hold on too long. Team-building isn’t about chasing stars; it’s about sustainability.

Russel Westbrook · Nov 21, 2024

@Lebron James, Russel Westbrick

rss